She said James Crumbley owned other guns and was tasked with storing them with a lock.ĭuring cross-examination, prosecutors suggested that while Jennifer Crumbley may have "entrusted" the responsibility of storing the 9 mm handgun to her husband after she took Ethan to the shooting range, it was "pretty clear you didn't trust James with much," noting that she had issues with his holding down a job, handling his money and even getting out of bed on time. When Crumbley took the stand, she testified that it was her husband who decided to buy Ethan a 9 mm Sig Sauer a day after Thanksgiving 2021. Video was shown to jurors of Jennifer Crumbley taking Ethan, then 15, to a shooting range the weekend before the massacre. Neither parent at the meeting warned the school they had just bought him a gun, which school staff members testified would have "completely changed the process that we followed." And his parents declined to take him home after the discussion was over, which prosecutors said at Jennifer Crumbley's trial were among the "many small things" that could have prevented the massacre later that day.Ī juror later told NBC News that she came to the conclusion that Jennifer Crumbley was criminally responsible because she was the last adult known to have had custody of the weapon before it was used in the shooting. James and Jennifer Crumbley were summoned to Oxford High School the morning of the shooting about a drawing their son had made of a gun, a person who was shot and a message, including: "The thoughts won't stop. Prosecutors at Jennifer Crumbley's trial called 21 witnesses, including law enforcement officials, co-workers of Crumbley and school staff members, in an effort to depict her as a mother who failed to notice her son's deteriorating mental health and had missed multiple warnings signs that her son was imminently planning to carry out a mass shooting. "Not only did they win a conviction, but it didn't take the jury long," Chutkow said of the deliberations, which lasted about 11 hours.Īs with Jennifer Crumbley, a jury must determine whether James Crumbley is guilty of involuntary manslaughter by either failing to store the firearm in a way that would have obstructed his son from gaining access to the gun and ammunition or failing to exercise "reasonable care" of his son and prevent him from carrying out the massacre. "Although the facts will be mostly the same, there are some advantages to the defense this time around." Similar strategyĬhutkow said he expects Oakland County prosecutors to use the same "playbook" against James Crumbley as they did with his wife, "because it worked." attorney's office in Detroit and is not affiliated with the case. A new set of jurors," said Mark Chutkow, a lawyer who previously led the criminal division of the U.S.
![among us thanksgiving coloring pages among us thanksgiving coloring pages](https://i.etsystatic.com/28968851/r/il/2ade3b/3077162082/il_1588xN.3077162082_p4ed.jpg)
Jennifer Crumbley, 45, often sobbed and hunched over in her seat as witnesses recalled the worst school shooting in Michigan's history. His wife's trial was marked by dramatic testimony surrounding the day of the shooting and video from Oxford High School in suburban Detroit.
![among us thanksgiving coloring pages among us thanksgiving coloring pages](https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-yk3kw4eQ7iw/UpIb2zf76qI/AAAAAAAACOE/vUPD8ymt_tQ/s1600/Thanksgiving-Coloring-Pages-For-Kids.jpg)
His trial on an identical charge of four counts of involuntary manslaughter - each one representing a student who was killed - begins Tuesday with jury selection. James Crumbley, 47, now gets his day in court in the unusual case. that a parent was held criminally responsible for a school shooting perpetrated by his or her child. Despite her attempt to deflect fault onto him after their son used a semi-automatic handgun bought by James Crumbley to kill four high school classmates in 2021, a jury found her guilty - the first time in the U.S.